If you love rich people behaving badly in a picture-perfect suburb, Aggie Blum Thompson is your author. The Neighbors Are Watching is set in Eastbrook, Bethesda, one of those leafy DC-area neighborhoods that looks flawless on the surface and is absolutely rotten underneath.
Caren blacks out shortly after leaving a graduation party and wakes up with a head wound near the house where a nanny was murdered a year ago. She thinks she was drugged. Her husband and the police aren't so sure. When she teams up with Finn, a new neighbor desperate to solve his best friend's murder, the two start pulling at threads that the whole neighborhood wants left alone.
This one has multiple POVs, a dual timeline, gaslighting, unreliable narrators, and characters making the worst possible decisions at every turn. It's a lot. And it works. The dual timeline was a smart structural choice; it let Thompson weave in the backstory of the original murder without it ever feeling like a detour.
The only two characters in this book NOT actively scheming or covering something up are Finn and his sassy landlord, which tells you everything you need to know. Oh, and Finn is a librarian. So he was automatically my favorite. π There's also a diverse cast and solid LGBTQ+ representation woven throughout.
Narrator Alex Picard handles a large, chaotic cast with real skill. I never once lost track of who was who, which is genuinely impressive given how many people are up to no good here.
My only quibble: the big reveal of who the killer was fell a little flat for me. Not a dealbreaker, but I wanted more of a gut punch at the end.
Still, if you need a perfect pool or beach listen this summer, this is your book. It's entertaining, twisty, and I wanted to yell at Caren to run from the toxic bougie neighborhood the entire time. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
π§ Thank you Macmillan Audio for the early listen! The Neighbors Are Watching by Aggie Blum Thompson is out June 30.
If you liked this review, you might be interested in The Dead Girls Book Club by Zia Rayyan.
About the Author
Before turning to fiction, Aggie Blum Thompson covered real-life crime as a newspaper reporter for a number of papers, including The Boston Globe and The Washington Post. Aggie is a member of Mystery Writers of America. She lives with her family in the suburbs of Washington, DC.
Follow Aggie on Instagram or visit her website to keep up with news and information about her books.













